Looks like the third time’s the charm for Billy Joel. Long Island’s Newsday reports that the Piano Man finally sold his beachfront home in Sagaponack, New York for $19 million.

That’s a bit of a markdown — Billy listed it in June for $19,950,000. But it’s well below the $23.5 million he asked for in 2009.

The house was built by the late Jaws star Roy Scheider. Billy purchased the four-story 5500-square-foot home with 145 feet of beachfront in 2007.